How does someone know which is the best mattress for them? This is a question many have wondered, probably now more than ever since we have so many options. Often, individuals tend to repurchase the same type of mattresses they had before, out of fear of making a costly mistake or because they are unsure of other options. Plus, researching products takes time, something many of us have little of to spare. In this guide, we will be sharing our research into different mattress types to provide a starting point. We will introduce and compare the four leading mattresses currently on the market so you will be better equipped to cut through the hype and choose a bed that meets your needs.
Innerspring, Coil, Pillowtops
This group comprises the traditional innerspring mattresses most people are familiar with. Coil mattresses were first introduced in the 19th century. Since industrialization, these have remained the most common mattress type in American homes.
A complete spring mattress consists of the boxspring base, the mattress springs, and padding layers. In each type, metal coils comprise the support system. There are several different types of spring systems in use, from connected Bonnell coils to independent pocketed springs. Quality is often represented by the gauge and number of coils. The lower the gauge, the less give the coils have, with 14-gauge considered high-quality. Coil count can be more arbitrary, but the idea is that the greater the number of coils, the better the bed can contour and support the sleeper. On top of the coils, manufacturers use foams, padding, and stuffing to provide a comfortable sleeping surface. They can range from basic quilting to memory foam or latex, and may be several inches thick.
Innerspring mattresses are easy to find, and are available in nearly every showroom. These are often the most affordable mattress types as well, for basic models at least. Innersprings also tend to rate higher for ease of movement on bed, and tend to receive less complaints for sleeping hot as compared to some foam mattresses.
While most common, these types of beds have the lowest owner happiness with only 60-65% of people reporting satisfaction. The biggest causes for complaint prove longevity and comfort issues. Innerspring beds to to wear faster than other types as the springs lose support and padding compresses. You can expect to replace an average innerspring mattress every 5-7 years. Motion transfer is another drawback, as the design does not prohibit one partner’s movements from disturbing the other. And with the big industry brands, price may not always match value and some models even exceed the costs of better-rated specialty mattresses.
Innerspring mattresses are widely available, sold at innumerable mattress stores across the country. Key brands in the industry include Simmons and Serta which all feature multiple lines of spring beds. Of these brands, satisfaction ratings tend to be fairly similar. There are also several other regional manufacturers and online sources for spring beds.
Memory foam mattresses were first introduced in the early 1990’s. NASA scientists invented the original concept of visco elastic foam, as a cushioning material to absorb the affects of G forces during take off, though they believed the concept would be best utilized in consumer applications. Memory foam is a unique material in that it contours to the shape of the sleeper, and distributes the applied weight evenly over its surface to eliminate pressure points caused by heavier areas like hips and shoulders.
These types of mattresses utilize fairly simple constructions that differ little between manufacturers. The “memory foam” portion of the mattress is the upper layer, which may be anywhere from 2-8 inches thick. This is supported by a base foam, which is typically denser and does not have memory properties (otherwise a sleeper would sink to the bottom). There may be multiple layers of foam with different properties, and some manufacturers will cut air channels into the layers to reduce heat. A bed with a spring core would be not be considered a true memory foam mattress.
The key differences you will encounter when shopping memory foam beds is the foam density and type. Optimal density ranges between 4.0-5.3 lb (per sq ft). Anything less is apt to breakdown and offer sub-standard support, while anything higher may be to viscous or firm for most people. Memory foam also comes in different formulations: standard (traditional visco foam, temperature sensitive, slow-response), plant-based (uses natural oils, more breathable and faster response), and gel infused (gel plus memory foam, marketed as cooler).
Overall, memory foam is the highest rated mattress in terms of owner happiness with about 80-83% of people reporting satisfaction. These are considered the best mattresses for individuals who suffer from back problems and other aches and pains, since the material supports natural alignment and does not place additional pressure on the body. Memory foam also maintains an advantage in longevity with quality beds lasting 10-20 years, and is the best at prohibiting motion transfer.
Though memory foam is the best-rated mattress, there are a couple of drawbacks reported by a percentage of owners. Traditional memory foam has come under fire for using many toxic components during the manufacturing process and for containing a host chemicals (especially imported foams). Some people also find memory foam to sleep hot, and some brands may give off strong odors initially. Newer versions like gel and plant based memory foam aim to make improvements in these areas. Memory foam also has a reputation for being expensive, though many brands are on par with quality spring beds nowadays.
Memory foam continues growing and is available throughout the states. Gel memory foam is also widely available under Serta’s lines. Plant-based types can be harder to locate locally, though Amerisleep.com ships their plant-based memory foam collection nationally.
The material for natural latex foam comes from living hevea brasiliensis trees. Latex mattresses have been around since the early 1900’s, when the Dunlop process made latex foam a viable product. Over the years, the process has expanded to include the Talalay process as well as synthetic latex and even organic latex. Initially, latex was very expensive but modern manufacturing has lowered the price considerably.
Latex mattresses feature one of the most simple constructions of all beds. A true latex mattress will actually contain only latex foam, as both the support core and comfort layers. After the foam is manufactured, it is cured, cut, and layered to create a bed. The layers may or may not be glued together, and the mattress can feature a range of covers from simple cotton to wool, and more.
Latex mattresses are typically distinguished on two factors: the manufacturing process and type of latex. The Dunlop process is the original method for making latex foam, which results in a durable, often firm product. The Talalay process is more controlled and yields a product touted as more consistent. Talalay typically costs more, though in actual reviews, the two types tend to perform similarly. The latex liquid from either type can be made of 100% natural latex, a synthetic chemically-derived latex, or a blend of both. Latex aficionados prefer the 100% natural product for its durability, eco-friendliness, and hypoallergenic properties.
100% natural mattresses are the second highest in term of owner satisfaction, averaging at 79-81%. These types of beds are highly durable, with expected lifespans of 15 or more years. This material also offers many of the benefits of memory foam like low-pressure support and natural contouring without the slow-response, chemical odors, or heat retention.
Latex mattresses tend to be a little more expensive than other mattress types, due to the cost of the materials used. This mattress type is also difficult to buy or try locally, as few national brands carry 100% natural latex beds.
Most people looking for a natural latex mattress end up shopping online, where one can find a variety of retailers with different types and features available. When comparing online retailers, you will want to check the mattress specifications and ensure the bed is returnable, especially if it will be your first time trying latex. One website that ships nationally is Astrabeds.com which offers 100% natural latex mattresses made with certified organic latex that rate well in reviews, with free shipping and a 90 day trial period.
Water beds have been around for very long time, with the modern vinyl version we know today debuting in the 1960s. Today, there are many variations on the classic with both hardside wood-frame models and softside waterbeds which can be used with standard furniture. The water chamber can be “free flow” in which nothing obstructs the flow of water (often disruptive for couples), or “waveless” in which fiber or baffles limit the motion. Waterbeds also tend to rank about 75%, with a steady base devotees despite the potential mess and hassle of maintenance. Very few mattress stores retail waterbeds, though local specialty shops and internet retailers remain a good resource.
Mattress Comparison Chart
|Types||Bonnell, Pocketed Spring, Continous Coil, etc||Tradiitonal, Gel, Plant-Based||Talalay/Dunlop, Natural/Synthetic||Hardside/ Softside, Freeflow/Waveless|
|Heat Complaints||Low||Low to Med||Low||Low|
|Odor Complaints||Low||Low to Med||Low||Low|
Shopping for a new mattress in today’s market can be quite the experience, with dozens of brands, models, and styles, and new technologies introduced every year. Part of choosing the best mattress involves knowing all of your options, and thoroughly researching your purchase. While each person’s idea of comfort will vary, reviews and ratings offer a good starting point especially if you have not shopped mattresses in a while or are looking for a change. In terms of ratings alone, the best mattresses on the market prove memory foam and latex, with over 4/5 owners of these two types reporting satisfaction. Many people opt for innersprings since specialty mattresses can be harder to find, but the internet has revolutionized mattress shopping with a much greater selection, more competitive pricing, and a wealth of information. We hope you found this introductory mattress guide useful, and always let us know if you have any mattress questions that need answers!